My partner is Rooster, I am Tiger. Hmm..

I know that chinese astrology indicates we may not be a good match, even our western zodiac signs indicate this, but if there was ever a true match on earth for me, I would say it's him. We agree almost all the time despite our differences in thinking, we have more in common with each other than anyone we've encountered in our pasts, and honestly the people I've been the 'most compatible' with I've had the worst relationships with. Why is that?