Tiger Female Sagittarius - Horse Male Sagittarius

Hi I had a date with a guy that strongly believes in the Chinese Zodiac. I came across this side, I was wondering how good we would do together? I saw we here super compatible but based on my experience with another a relationship with another horse Gemini and it was a total disaster, he cheated and since the second month and lied even when I caught him. So having a bad experience with "horses" per say