Partner

Good day! :)
I am Mary Mae, Female, born on March 27, 1993.
I've been dating a guy whose date of birth is on June 23, 1991. We've been together for more than four years not until something happened between us involving trust issues. He cheated on me before, and recently, I also got involved with another guy whose date of birth is on August 17, 1990. I have fallen in love with the second guy though but I fear that being with him could be a mistake.
I am confused now to whom i should choose. Hope I could hear from you. Thanks! :)